The holiday season is often associated with joy, warmth, and togetherness. However, for many, it can also trigger stress, anxiety, and feelings of being pulled back into old, dysfunctional roles within the family. As families reunite, individuals often slip back into familiar patterns, even if those roles are unhealthy or unhelpful.
Whether you're the responsible "caretaker," the rebellious "black sheep," or the "scapegoat" who absorbs blame, these old dynamics can feel impossible to escape. Understanding the psychological impact of these roles and learning strategies to manage them can help make family gatherings more positive, or at least more manageable.
The Psychology Behind Family Roles
Family systems theory, developed by psychologist Murray Bowen , suggests that families function as emotional units where patterns of behavior, often unconsciously, are passed down from one generation to the next. These patterns create roles, or specific ways in which family members interact with each other, often tied to past unresolved issues. In dysfunctional families, these roles can be particularly rigid, limiting personal growth and contributing to feelings of isolation, guilt, or frustration. During the holidays, when family members come together, these roles tend to resurface, bringing with them old conflicts and unresolved emotions.
Common Family Roles
The Caretaker: The person who feels responsible for everyone’s well-being, often at the expense of their own emotional health.
The Scapegoat: The one who is blamed for family issues, often taking the fall for problems that aren't entirely their fault.
The Hero: The family overachiever, who works to keep up appearances, striving to create the image of a perfect family.
The Rebel: The family member who challenges authority and rejects traditional expectations, often as a way to deflect attention from their inner pain or dissatisfaction.
The Invisible One: The person who withdraws, avoiding conflict and trying to go unnoticed during family interactions.
The Clown: The one who uses humor or distraction to avoid serious topics, often masking their own pain or discomfort with jokes and lightheartedness.
The Peacemaker: The family member who steps in to calm tensions and smooth over conflicts, often at the cost of their own emotional needs.
The Impact of Family Reunions
Even if we have successfully worked on changing these roles in other areas of our lives, the emotional pull of family dynamics can still pull us back into old patterns. This is known as regression, a psychological phenomenon where we revert to earlier, less mature ways of thinking, feeling, or behaving when we feel threatened or overwhelmed .
For those trapped in unhealthy roles, these gatherings can feel overwhelming and emotionally exhausting. Whether it’s dealing with criticism, navigating passive-aggressive behavior, or feeling like you’ve regressed to an earlier version of yourself, these encounters can undermine your well-being and sense of self-worth. This is why we may feel like we "lose ourselves" when we're around certain family members, or why we slip into behaviors we’ve worked so hard to outgrow.
Psychologist Dr. John Gottman’s research on family dynamics highlights how negative patterns of communication . Family reunions can reactivate these negative cycles, bringing out the worst in all parties involved. However, understanding the dynamics at play can provide a sense of agency. Recognizing the roles people are playing in the family system gives you the power to decide whether you want to participate in or perpetuate these patterns.
Psychological and Emotional Symptoms During and After Family Reunions
After or during family reunions, especially those involving complex or dysfunctional dynamics, many people experience a range of psychological and emotional symptoms. These can vary depending on an individual’s family history, the specific roles they play within their family, and the nature of family relationships. Below are some common symptoms people might experience during or after family reunions, along with some explanations based on psychological principles:
Anxiety and DepressionAnxiety during family gatherings can stem from unresolved issues, past trauma, or the anticipation of judgment. Those with attachment wounds such as described by Bowlby, may fear rejection, criticism, or not meeting family expectations.
Emotional Exhaustion or BurnoutPeople often give more than they can handle emotionally in such gatherings. The emotion regulation required to manage family tensions and managing family dynamics or diffusing conflicts can be taxing and overwhelming .
Overwhelming Guilt or ShameFamily members might experience overwhelming guilt or shame. They may feel like they’re under constant pressure to be perfect and may struggle with feelings of blame .
Feeling Triggered or OverwhelmedDuring family gatherings, especially those involving old patterns of behavior, people may feel "triggered" by comments, actions, or dynamics that remind them of past traumas or unresolved conflicts and may experience emotional outbursts or sudden tears, even in response to small triggers (Van der Kolk, 2014). There may also be an intense desire to escape or avoid family members or specific situations.
Withdrawal or Emotional ShutdownWithdrawal can be a protective mechanism. People may shut down emotionally to avoid feeling vulnerable or to escape family conflict and become silent, distant, or avoid eye contact (Schore, 2003).
Anger or ResentmentSudden outbursts of anger, frustration, or irritability may appear towards family members, especially if old patterns of blame or control are activated. Ruminating about family issues or feeling resentful after the reunion, even the desire to “lash out” and confront family members, may arise.
A Sense of "Not Belonging" or IsolationFeeling alienated or disconnected from the family, a sense of being an outsider or that your needs or emotions are unimportant is often present in individuals whose emotional needs were neglected in the past (Keren, 2014).
Self-Criticism and PerfectionismThe need to meet high family standards or to "fix" family problems can lead to a constant cycle of self-judgment and may lead to being hypercritical of oneself and focusing on perceived flaws or mistakes (Shafran & Mansell, 2001).
Post-Event Reflection and RuminationAfter family reunions, individuals often engage in rumination, particularly if there were unresolved conflicts or emotional tensions. They may find themselves replaying conversations or events, trying to make sense of or understand the dynamics that unfolded.
Somatic SymptomsEmotional stress and psychological overload during family reunions can manifest physically, such as headaches, stomachaches, or other unexplained physical discomfort, insomnia, and change in appetite .
Strategies for Coping with Dysfunctional Family Roles
If you're finding yourself slipping back into an old family role during the holidays, here are some strategies to help you navigate these dynamics more effectively:
Set Clear BoundariesBoundaries are essential to protecting your emotional well-being, especially when old family roles start to resurface. Boundaries could include saying no to excessive demands, limiting the amount of time you spend with certain family members, or establishing physical and emotional space when needed. According to Therapist and Author Dr. Harriet Lerner , setting healthy boundaries is a key way to maintain self-respect and emotional health.
Self-Awareness: Recognize the Role You’re PlayingSelf-awareness is the first step in breaking free from old family roles. Before you attend a family gathering, take a moment to reflect on the roles you tend to slip into during past holidays. Awareness of these patterns allows you to make intentional choices rather than unconsciously reverting back to the same behaviors .
Develop a Self-Care PlanHaving a self-care plan in place will help you recharge and protect your mental health. This might involve setting aside time for relaxation, engaging in physical activity, or doing activities that make you feel grounded and centered.
Develop Self-CompassionPracticing self-compassion helps by encouraging the individual to treat themselves with the same kindness and understanding that they would extend to others suggested Kristin Neff.
Seek Support family gatherings are particularly difficult, it can be helpful to seek support before or after the event. Speaking with a therapist can help you process any difficult emotions and prepare for challenging situations. If you’re not in therapy, surrounding yourself with key resourcing people can be valuable.
Family dynamics can be complex, and during the holiday season, old patterns often re-emerge. By understanding the psychological roles that tend to take center stage and using coping tools to break free from them, you can approach family gatherings with more awareness and emotional resilience. The goal isn’t to change everyone else—but to create a healthier, more authentic version of yourself within the family system. Remember, the holiday season is about creating new memories, building stronger relationships, and finding peace within yourself, regardless of the roles others may try to cast you in.
Comments